Felicity's New Sister is part of the Short Stories collections, focusing on Felicity Merriman.


From the Central Series


Story Summary

Felicity's New Sister 1

Rose catches Felicity leaving.

Felicity closes the back door and starts to sneak across the back porch on a December morning. She thinks that the day is a perfect, crisp day and that the perfect start off to the morning would be to take a ride on Penny. Felicity jumps off the porch and starts to run towards the stables, thinking to herself how Penny will go faster than ever—and her thoughts are cut off by but a voice asking where she thinks she's going. Felicity thinks—unhappily—that she's been caught and turns around to see Rose standing at the door with her arms crossed. Rose reminds Felicity that her mother expects her to be a part of her breakfast party. Felicity frowns and tries to argue, but Rose remains firm and directs Felicity to change into some nicer clothes. Felicity sighs as she trudges back to the house. Rose tells Felicity kindly that while would rather ride her horse, her mother needed lots of help with the baby coming and being the eldest sister is a responsibility Felicity can't run away from. She tries to cheer up Felicity by saying she made a tart for her breakfast, but Felicity isn't cheered up by the thought; she is quite tired of being indoors and feels like she has been cooped up all December. Mother is pregnant and has needed Felicity's help around the house since she can't move much; primarily, Felicity has had to take care of Nan and William when she is resting and this leaves Felicity very little time to play outdoors. She also has had to help when holiday callers come visiting, and heard guests drone about births, deaths, and marriages. As she gets dressed in her petticoat and jacket, Felicity thinks sourly on how much work the new baby has caused her already and that all this work has made the winter dull. She thinks that she'll have even more work when the baby is actually born, and wishes she wasn't the oldest sister.
Felicity's New Sister 2

Felicity greets Mrs. Wentworth.

Felicity doesn't feel very spirited as she walks down the stairs; they drop even more when she sees that the breakfast guest is Mrs. Wentworth, who Felicity thinks is the most talkative woman in all of Virginia. Nan and William are already at the table, and Felicity curtsies at the doorway. Mrs. Wentworth nods at her and continues talking to Martha. She tells Martha she needs a rest and should go to her father's plantation for the rest; she herself is headed back home Thursday and invites the Merrimans to join her; Mr. Merriman can follow them later. Felicity loves the idea and asks if they could go—partially because Grandfather's plantation has plenty of servants that can help Mother and look after Nan and William which will leave her with plenty of free time.

Before Mother can answer, Rose rattled the plates she is holding, causing her and Felicity to look at her. Rose says nothing, but has a look of disapproval. Mother explains to Mrs. Wentworth that for days, Rose has cautioned her that the baby is due sooner than is expected and that Rose thinks she shouldn't go far from home; when prompted, Rose confirms the idea firmly. Felicity is quickly angry at Rose and then happy when Mrs. Wentworth says that the midwife has said the baby isn't coming soon—and that she doubts that Rose knows as much about babies as the midwife did. Martha says that Rose had been with her since before Felicity's birth and she knew a great deal about babies. Mother starts to say something else when Felicity (unable to contain herself further) says please, they must go as it's been a dull winter and it's the last chance for fun—trailing off that it's the last chance before the baby arrives. Martha smiles indulgently and that they'll go, as she has felt guilty somewhat that Felicity has had no time to herself and will have even less once the baby is born, and they could all use a change. Rose sighs as the children cheer, and Mrs. Wentworth says that they'll take her carriage bright and early Thursday morning.

Thursday morning is neither bright nor early when the carriage arrives; it is a rainy afternoon. The luggage is loaded quickly and Rose sets her own bag under the seat next to the driver where she'll be riding. The others get into the carriage and they head off. The air is stuffy, and Nan and William are soon both asleep. Mrs. Wentworth talks on and on, with only small interjections from Martha; she keeps jabbing Felicity with her elbow when the carriage jounces. Felicity is impatient to get to the plantation and looks out the window at the dreary view. The muddy road leads past black trees, empty fields, and gray stone walls.

About ten miles outside of Williamsburg just past an abandoned house, the road dips into a gully; the rain has caused a stream. The carriage drives into the gully and the wheels slip on the bank; the carriage lurches and slams to a stop that jostles everyone inside. Nan and William cry out in fright as Mrs. Wentworth cries for Caleb to help them. Felicity hears a crack and looks down to see that the floor of the carriage has split, letting water seep inside. The carriage is tilting so far to one side that it feels as if it could topple into the water.

Mrs. Wentworth shrieks for help again, and wants to know what happened. Caleb and Rose slosh through the water; Caleb wrenches the door open and tells them that the carriage crashed into the bank. The carriage undercarriage is cracked and the horse is lame. Rose tells everyone to get out of the carriage quickly before it falls over. Mrs. Wentworth insists that Martha leave first; she and Rose help her out, then as Caleb helps Martha up out of the water Rose helps Mrs. Wentworth leave next. Rose tells the children to make haste, but Nan and William shrink back into the carriage in fear. Rose tells Felicity that she should go first to help them out of the carriage. Felicity hesitates, and Rose tells her to hurry for the water is rising.

Felicity's New Sister 3

Felicity helps her siblings out of the damaged carriage.

Felicity wants to cry out that she's scared too, but she looks at her sibling's faces and, feeling sorry for them, realizes that they are too scared to move and she has to go first and act braver than she feels. Felicity pushes herself out the door, landing in the icy cold water and almost falling to her knees. Once she has her footing, she turns to the carriage and holds out her arms to tell William that she'll catch him. He slides into her arms and she holds him close. Felicity then turns to Nana and says it's her turn and not to be afraid---the water is only to Felicity's ankles, and so isn't so deep. Nan inches her way out, and wails that the water is cold when she steps in. Felicity agrees and that they should hurry out of the water. Nan makes her way up and Felicity follows carrying William.

Caleb leads everyone to the deserted house near by; it is cold and dark, but dry. Caleb starts a fire once they're inside and everyone crowds around it; Martha looks pale. Mrs. Wentworth orders Caleb to walk to Williamsburg and get help while they wait in the house and to make haste, as the wet clothes are making her uncomfortable. He says he'll be back as soon as he can and leaves. Rose adds some logs to the fire and Felicity takes her cloak off to dry. Moments later Martha gasps and holds her side, and Rose rushes to her; Martha says that she thinks the baby is coming. Felicity worries while Mrs. Wentworth says that it's nonsense as she twists water out of her petticoats. Martha goes quiet, and then gasps again and bites her lip. Mrs. Wentworth, looking alarmed, says that Martha must be sensible and mustn't have the baby now. Rose replies back that babies don't wait as she helps Martha to her feet, and they must get ready to do all they can. Mrs. Wentworth says she knows nothing about babies but goes with them into the next room.

Felicity, trembling with fear, thinks that it's all her fault for begging to go to the plantation and that Mother and the baby are in danger from it. Before she can continue her thoughts William takes Felicity's hand and asks if Mother is having her baby, his face white. Felicity recalls Rose telling her that being the eldest sister is a responsibility she can't run away from. She takes a shaky breath, squeezes her brother's hand, and tells him not to worry because Rose will take care of Mother and she will take care of him and Nan; she says that they will all be fine, as she silently hopes that this is true.

Felicity helps Nan and William make themselves comfortable, helping them out of their stockings and shoes and rubbing their feet dry. She sings to them to keep them calm whenever Mother is heard moaning or crying out in pain. Soon, it's quiet from the other room. William and Nan fall asleep, but Felicity is too scared to sleep. She tries to listen to the noises in the other room, but there aren't any. Felicity is still wide awake when Rose opens the door and motions Felicity to come over. When Felicity arrives, she asks her to do a hard thing—her bag is still under the seat and it has things that will help Martha, and she needs Felicity to fetch it. Felicity, without hesitation, says she'll go. Rose calls her brave and to hurry. Felicity makes her way quickly through the rain and over the slick ground to the gully; the bank is so slick she slides down on her bottom. She wades through the water to the carriage and gets Rose's bag, which is wet but otherwise unharmed. Felicity carries it close to her chest with both hands and back through the dark and the deserted house. Rose is waiting just inside the door and takes the bag before going back to the other room. Martha cries out; Felicity can hear Rose and Mrs. Wentworth soothing and encouraging her.

Felicity's New Sister 4

Mrs. Merriman calls Felicity over after the birth.

Felicity then hears a tiny mew (like a kitten) that slowly becomes a loud, strong wail—it's the baby. She creeps to the other room, which is only lit by a single candle. Mrs. Merriman, lying on a makeshift bed, smiles and tells Felicity to come see her new sister. Felicity's legs feel weak as she walks over and kneels by her mother's side, before looking at the face in the bundle Rose is holding. She suddenly feels pride and love at her new baby sister. Mrs. Wentworth puts a hand on Felicity's shoulder and admits shakily that she was an old fool—but not foolish enough that she couldn't admit her being wrong and that Rose did know more than the midwife. She wouldn't have been able to help the baby be born without Rose's help, and thanks god Rose was there. Rose thanks Mrs. Wentworth, then smiles at Felicity and says that everyone has to help any way they can when a baby arrives. Felicity smiles with pride.

Rose carefully hands the baby over to Felicity, commenting that she was almost born in a stream like a pollywog. Felicity suggests they name the new baby 'Polly', short for polliwog. Mrs. Merriman agrees to the name, saying that this way they would never forget the night she was born. Felicity looks at Polly's face and exclaims that she will never forget the night that she became a sister all over again.

Meet The Author

Valerie recalls her and her sister's excitement at the birth of her younger brother, Granger. He was born before Christmas and she feels that he was the best gift any of them could have imagined and she and her sisters were all pleased to become a sister again.

Looking Back: Babies in 1774

Discusses birth and infancy during Colonial times. Topics include:

  • How childbirth was handled and how long a mother would rest after the birth
  • The importance of christening for babies
  • How parents would choose names that reflected virtues
  • The role of godparents, who were chosen during the christening
  • How a baby's birth was celebrated
  • The popularity of pincushions as a baby gift and why pins were needed
  • The act of swaddling babies, wrapping them in long strips of cloth to straighten their bones
  • How babies in Colonial times learned how to walk
  • What kind of clothes babies and young children would wear


Make a Colonial baby gift, an embroidered and tassled pin cushion.

Items associated with Felicity's New Sister


Felsismagazine1s Felsismagazine2s
Original Illustrations from American Girl Magazine.


  1. Polly's portrait explicitly states that she was born December 1775; furthermore, Penny is now property of the Merriman family.
Community content is available under CC-BY-SA unless otherwise noted.